- A conservatorship grants court-appointed people the power to make estate planning decisions for someone who is incapacitated and unable to manage their affairs
- There are two forms of conservatorship: Probate Conservatorship and Lanterman Petris-Short Conservatorship
- A guardianship gives an individual the authority to decide on physical and mental matters of someone who is deemed unable to do so by the courts
- Reasons for conservatorship or guardianship appointments include: dementia, Alzheimer’s disease, coma and mental illness
- There are vetting procedures in place to protect wards and their assets
- There are other ways for an individual, providing they are of sound mind, to choose an agent to care for their affairs such as Power of Attorney or Revocable Trust
An individual’s capabilities are prone to change over the span of a lifetime, and while people in general may have an innate desire to maintain their autonomy and independence indefinitely, the realities of aging and illness often place a damper on this preference. When time comes when it is found that a person is no longer able to make sound decisions regarding their health needs and best financial interests, appointing a guardian or conservator to act on their behalf often becomes the best solution.
We hope this article will serve as a resource for individuals who are in the process of deciding whether to avail themselves of this option, and to shed light on the workings of guardianships and conservatorships.
A conservatorship, also referred to as a guardianship of the estate, typically grants one or more court-appointed people the power to make estate planning decisions on financial matters for someone who is found to be unable to manage their affairs due to infirmity or impairment.
If the court finds that the conservatee is capable of having some input on these matters then a limited conservatorship will be granted. This allows the conservatee a greater say in certain areas. A conservator’s job in those cases usually involves managing the economic resources of the individual deemed to some degree unfit. Depending on the circumstances. Acting for the conservatee, these duties may extend to:
- Acquiring and managing assets, such as properties and funds
- Buying food and other needs
- Securing and paying for placement in a facility to treat a mental illness or otherwise look after the conservatee
- Pay other bills
- Manage property by paying for property insurance, rent or mortgages, property clean-up, or pay for a property management company to maintain and rent the property
There are two forms of conservatorship:
This entails a court-appointed person to care for someone who is unable to care for themselves or their assets for reasons found sufficient by the courts.
Any individual can petition the courts to initiate this process. Sufficient evidence of the conservatee’s inability to manage their affairs is required prior to the appointment of a conservator. A probate conservator’s appointment is usually permanent.
This is a specific type of conservatorship that gives an individual authority over a person with a verified mental disorder that is found in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders(DSM), a list of diagnosed mental illnesses.
These are commonly used for people who are incapacitated due to mental illness, and they require involuntary treatment or court-mandated placement into a health care facility. Because more power is granted to an LPS conservatorship, a thorough evaluation at the hands of designated professionals is needed to initiate the process. The conservatorship is granted for 30 days initially and, if needed, thereafter extended for a year, with annual extensions upon re-applying.
The “ward” is the person in regard to whom a court appoints a guardian. A guardianship of a person gives an individual the authority to decide on matters relating to the physical and mental well-being of an individual who, following an investigation, is deemed unable to do so by the courts. In some instances, a “plenary guardianship” extends to both the person and their estate. The powers of the legal guardian may be broad or limited depending on the capacity of their ward and their other arrangements. The duties of the plenary guardian include:
- Deciding where the person will live
- Providing for the care, comfort, education, social recreational needs, and overall well-being of the ward
- Caring for the clothing, furniture, vehicles and other personal effects of the ward
- Managing the ward’s assets when there is no guardian of the estate
- Requesting money from the guardian of the estate to pay for the ward’s care
- Consenting or withholding consent to medical care, including admission to a hospital or nursing home, with certain limitations
During court proceedings, a guardian “ad litem” may be appointed; this is someone appointed to act on behalf of the ward in a court case. Their duties are to:
- Act in the ward’s best interests
- Evaluate the capacity of the ward
- Investigate the parties involved, including potential guardians, wards, and other relevant persons.
- Report their findings to the court
Guardians and conservators are appointed to individuals who are either too young to be autonomous or are mentally or physically incapacitated and unable on their own to make proper legal, medical, and financial decisions. The authority of the guardian may be limited in accordance with the degree of their ward’s incapacity. Reasons for these appointments include:
- Dementia: an illness that is denoted by the progressive deterioration of mental faculties and memory
- Alzheimer’s: a neurodegenerative disease that ultimately inhibits one’s ability to perform daily tasks
- Coma: a prolonged or permanent state of deep unconsciousness
- Mental illness: including numerous disorders that may render individuals unable to perform daily function tasks
While the particular methods and laws regarding the appointment of a conservator or guardian differ slightly from state to state, they tends to follow these basic parameters:
- A petition for guardianship or conservatorship is prepared and filed to the appropriate court
- A request is made prior to the hearing, when needed, for a temporary guardian to act as fiduciary for the ward
- The concerned parties are notified of an upcoming hearing; these would include other potential conservators or guardians, the potential conservatee, family members, partners or spouses, and other interested entities
- A court-appointed investigator reports their findings to the court
- A hearing will then be held approximately two months after the position has been filed to determine if a conservatorship or guardianship has been awarded, and the extent of its powers
- If the conservatee or another interested entity has an issue with the court’s previous decision, and they wish to alter or reverse it, then the necessary documents for an appeal must be submitted to the court of appeals
Appointing a guardian or conservator can be difficult and costly, and one of the more difficult aspects of this process can be the task of vetting those interested and qualified to hold this position.
Those who tend to be granted the position of of guardian or conservator are usually competent and interested relatives or court-appointed attorneys. Given the high potential for exploitation or misuse that such an appointment would afford a guardian or conservator, individuals with outstanding debts or criminal records are eliminated as a matter of course.
The conditions that must be met by potential guardians and conservators have been the subject of federal inquiries. The Government Accountability Organization(GAO) continually look into the prevalence of exploitation, neglect and abuse of seniors in the guardianship system, and why these misuses of authority are possible. GAO investigators focus on instances in which guardians used their power to embezzle or misappropriate, or those who stole or improperly obtained assets from incapacitated victims.
In the majority of cases, the GAO found that the potential guardians were poorly vetted, and that there was inadequate scrutiny of guardians or conservators after they were assigned the position. In addition, in an effort to determine the extent of the problem, the GAO made use of fake personas to satisfy the stipulations for guardianship certification in several states, only to find that the courts involved in many instances did not perform proper background checks on the fake applicants. To protect wards and their assets from those who would abuse them, courts have devised a myriad of vetting procedures in place for finding potential guardians. The conditions that must be met may differ depending on where the case has been filed, but there are some basic rules:
- The individual must be 18 years of age or older to hold this position
- They must understand and be able to execute their duties
- They must be of sound mind
- They must demonstrate the ability to create a suitable care plan
- They must agree to have a full background checks performed
- They must have no felony convictions
- They must not have a history of abuse or neglect
- They may need prior experience or education in performing the tasks that come with this appointment
- They may be required to obtain licenses and/or certifications prior to be granted guardianship
After being appointed the guardian must:
- Put up a security bond if caring for the estate of a protected person, to provide assurance that assets will be properly managed
- File reports regarding the protected person and their assets as often as is demanded by the courts
- Set up a separate account that can be used exclusively for matters relevant to the ward; guardians are not supposed to mix their assets with those of their wards
- Perform their fiduciary duties and responsibilities for their ward
- Participate in educational programs, if necessary, so that they can become better versed with the laws, regulations, and duties relating to their position
While there are obviously good intentions behind conservatorships and guardianships, many criticize them as violations of individual rights. There are numerous cases of these appointments being made in unwarranted or arbitrary manners where the protections intended to defend the ward and their estate failed:
- In March of 2008, a guardian embezzled over $640,000 from their charge, an 87-year old man in Missouri. Authorities found the victim living in filthy conditions and severely dehydrated. The guardian was sentenced to 8 years in prison and ordered to pay restitution for all that he had stolen. This case was particularly problematic because the guardian was a convicted felon, yet was able to gain control of the victim’s affairs by claiming to be the senior’s prior caretaker.
- A District of Columbia guardian violated the obligations conferred upon her by entrusting her responsibilities to her secretary who misappropriated almost $50,000 from two elderly individuals who were supposed to be under the care of her boss; one of these women lost their home due to unpaid property taxes.
- Two public guardians for a county government in California pilfered over $97,000 from 20 public wards. Exploitation of these vulnerable individuals was able to continue partially because of substandard court supervision of cases handled by the Public Guardian’s Office. Considering the court’s poor management, it is not unlikely that they stole from more people as well.
It is possible for an individual, providing they are of sound mind, to appoint individuals to choose an agent to care for their affairs. Appointing people to serve as agents or executors should they become incapacitated can help protect against undesirable outcomes from a court-appointed conservator or guardian who may or may not have known them prior to their impaired state. Here are some measures that you can take to maintain some degree of control:
A power of attorney is a document in which an individual, referred to as the principal or grantor, appoints someone else, referred to as the agent or attorney-in-fact. The agent is granted the ability to act on behalf of the principal in the capacity specified in the document on certain matters, such as financial, business, medical, legal, and more. Though these powers tend to be limited and will expire if the principal is medically incapacitated or dies, the principal can determine when and how their agent can utilize their powers depending on what they believe they require.
This is a type power of attorney that grants an agent the authority to act on the grantor’s behalf to some degree even after they have become incapacitated.
This document endows an individual with the right to make healthcare decisions for the principal when they are unable to give consent or their ability to do so is limited to a sufficient degree.
A revocable trust can be put in place with a reliable entity or set of entities serving as trustees to hold the assets of another person.
This is an individual or organization assigned to handle payments from welfare or other entitlement programs for another person who is unable to manage them.
Though many powers may be granted to a legal guardian or conservator, these positions do not give conservators absolute and perpetual control over the lives or affairs of their wards. There are numerous checks and balances in place to prevent or limit potential abuse, and there are situations that can lead to the termination of a guardianship or conservatorship. Here are circumstances that may lead to the dissolution of this contract:
- A guardian or conservatorship can be terminated if a ward is found to be able to manage their own affairs.
- If a guardian or conservator has been found to be either abusing or neglecting their position.
- If the appointment of guardian or conservatorship is successfully contested by an interested party, for example the parents.
- The ward has reached an age where they can be considered an adult
- The ward died
- The ward’s move to another state may cause the conservatorship to be terminated
- The conservator or guardian requests termination of the arrangement
Because conservatorships and guardianships entail such high levels of trust and responsibilities, families seeking to protect loved ones from an uncertain future need to exercise utmost due diligence. Appointing a guardian or conservator can be helpful, but it should by no means be the first or only course of action pursued by those who look after a loved one who is incapacitated. If you are considering this avenue, the first thing to do is to educate yourself as much as possible and, if feasible, seek the counsel of a legal professional. As you are likely aware, matters concerning the care of vulnerable loved persons are not trifle matters and, when handled carelessly, may prove incredibly costly.
- Conservatorship: When an individual is given the authority to manage the affairs of someone who has been determined unfit to make decisions regarding their estate.
- Conservator: An individual granted the authority to act on behalf of another in regard to their estate due to a reduction in capacity to manage their financial affairs.
- Conservatee: The person who has been deemed unfit to act in their best financial interests.
- Guardianship: When someone is authorized to make legal, financial, and healthcare decisions on behalf of a person who has been found incapable to make such choices.
- Guardianship of a person: An individual charged with the management of a court-protected person’s physical and mental needs.
- Guardianship of estate: An individual who has been tasked with the management and care of their ward’s assets.
- Plenary guardianship: A guardianship of the person and estate.
- Guardian ad litem: A court-appointed person to act as a fiduciary for an incapacitated individual and provide information during legal proceedings.
- Guardian: An individual who is given the authority to make legal, financial, and health care choices for someone who is incapacitated.
- Ward: Person who requires a guardian, due to a lack of capacity.
- Estate (legal): The totality of a person’s assets.
- Court order: A decree from a court or judge compelling the entity or person in question to act in accordance with some matter,
- Capacity: The ability to act in some manner.